by Joanne Cantor
Professor, Department of Communication Arts,
University of Wisconsin
Since 1980, the main focus of my research
has been to explore how the mass media frighten children.
My interest is in how children's exposure to a single
program or movie can produce intense worries, nightmares,
and other fear-related outcomes. Through a series of experiments
and surveys, and through the examination of retrospective
reports by adults of their childhood experiences, I have
discovered that intense and disruptive fears are produced
by teleivsion and movies much more often than most people
realize. For example, in a recent random phone survey
we conducted in Madison, Wisconsin, 43 percent of the
parents interviewed said that their child had been so
frightened by something they had seen on television that
the fear had lasted beyond the time of viewing. Intense
and long-lasting emotional reactions, sleep disturbances,
and fear of engaging in normal activities were fairly
common responses.
More striking than these numbers,
when we asked first-year university students whether
they had ever had a lingering fright reaction to a television
program or movie, we found an overwhelming response.
The students were given the same amount of "extra-credit"
in a class, either for saying "no (they had never
had such a reaction) or for saying "yes";
but the "yes" response required them to describe
the experience in a one-page paper and then fill out
a three-page questionnaire. To my amazement, 96 of the
103 students given this option chose the "yes"
response, and most of them gave graphic and emotional
descriptions of the terror that had been produced by
a movie or TV show. Almost half of these students said
that what they had seen had interfered with their eating
or sleeping. More than three-fourths of them said that
their reactions had lasted a week or more, and one-fourth
said that they were still feeling the residue of the
fear that the program or movie had produced, even though
they had been exposed to it an average of more than
a decade earlier.
The bulk of my research on this topic
has been aimed at understanding the types of media images
and events that frighten children at different ages
and the intervention and coping strategies that are
effective for children in different age groups. Using
theories and research in cognitive development, we have
reached the following generalizations based on our experiemntal
and survey results.
For preschool ("preoperational")
children (approximately age 2 to 7), how something looks
is the most important determinant of whether it will
be scary. At this age, Children's thought processes
are dominated by whatever is most readily perceptible
and whatever does not require reasoning to comprehend.
Preschoolers are especially frightened by media images
of vicious, attacking animals, "repulsive"
creatures, like snakes, bats, and spiders, the graphic
display of injuries and physical deformities, and monsters.
Preschool children are especially frightened by character
transformations, such as when a normal person turns
into a vampire before their eyes. They also have trouble
understanding that a monstrous looking hero is not a
villain. Since they are not fully competent in the fantasy-reality
distinction, the fact that something is blatantly fantastic
or impossible does not make it less scary. For older
elementary school ("concrete operational")
children (ages 8 to 12), the importance of how things
look diminishes, as these children begin to take motives
into account, reason more abstractly, and understand
the difference between fantasy and things that can atually
happen. They become more and more likely to be frightened
by real stories (like those shown in television news
and reality programming) and by fiction that makes them
aware of their own vulnerabilities to harm.
AS FOR HELPING CHILDREN COPE with
the media-induced fears, preschool children are helped
mainly by nonverbal strategies involving physical comfort,
warmth, and closeness (e.g., a mother's hug, or a warm
drink) or distraction (reducing their exposure to the
frightening stimulus or getting involved in other activities).
A fear that is not overwhelming can also respond to
desensitization (gradul exposure in manageable doeses).
Older children benefit more from fear-reduction strategiees
based on reasoning. If the fear-producing show was a
fantasy, a reminder that what was seen was not real
helps this age group. But for things that really can
happen, fear-reduction is more difficult. Honest, absolute,
reassuring information may help, but explanations focusing
on a dreadful event's low probability are relatively
ineffective. Information about how to prevent the dreaded
event from happening is welcomed at this age. And the
sincere, concerned attention of a parent or adult care-giver
is what children of all ages seem to seek the most when
they are frightened.
I HAVE PUBLISHED THESE FINDINGS in
a variety of scholarly outlets, and I have recently
completed a book aimed at an audience of parents and
other child-care providers (with academics and mental
health professionals as a secondary audience). The book
is titled "Mommy, I'm Scared! How Television and
Films Frighten Children and How We Can Protect Them."
It will be published by Harcourt Brace and is due out
in 1998.
Reprinted from "News on Children and Violence
on the Screen" by The UNESCO International Clearinghouse
on Children and Violence on the Screen, at Nordicom,
Gvteborg University, Sweden.
|